by Fred W. Anson
Here’s a challenge: Read through the following and try to guess who wrote it.
When It’s Love
Hey, everybody’s lookin’ for somethin’
Somethin’ to fill in the holes
We think a lot but don’t talk much about it
’til things get out of control, oh
How do I know when it’s love?
I can’t tell you but it lasts forever
Oh, how does it feel when it’s love?
It’s just somethin’ you feel together
When it’s love
You look at every face in a crowd
Some shine and some keep you guessin’
Waiting for someone to come into focus
And teach you your final love lesson, oh
How do I know when it’s love?
I can’t tell you but it lasts forever
Oh, how does it feel when it’s love?
It’s just something you feel together
Oh, when it’s love
You can feel it, yeah
Nothin’s missin’, yeah
Yeah, you can feel it
Oh, when it’s love
When nothin’s missing
How do I know when it’s love?
I can’t tell you but it lasts forever
Ooh, how does it feel when it’s love?
It’s just something you feel together, hey
How do I know when it’s love?
I can’t tell you but it lasts forever
When it’s love
Ooh, when it’s love
Hey, it’ll last forever
When it’s love
Give it up
We’re gonna feel this thing
Together
When it’s love, ooh
When it’s love, baby
You can feel it, yeah
We’ll make it last forever
Ooh, when it’s love
Who did you guess? Perhaps it was Blaise Pascal who I quoted in my last recontextualization article as saying…
“There is a God-shaped vacuum in the heart of every person, and it can never be filled by any created thing. It can only be filled by God, made known through Jesus Christ.”
– from “Pensees”
… after all the poem starts with, “everybody’s lookin’ for somethin’, somethin’ to fill in the holes” in true Pascalian fashion.
Or perhaps, you thought of St. Augustine who wrote…
“Thou hast formed us for Thyself, and our hearts are restless till they find rest in Thee”
— from “Confessions”
… when you considered the lines that said, “You look at every face in a crowd – some shine and some keep you guessin’. Waiting for someone to come into focus and teach you your final love lesson.” Isn’t that how Augustine might have put it had he written in the English vernacular of 20th Century America rather than in 4th Century Latin?
Or perhaps when you considered the words, “how does it feel when it’s love? It’s just something you feel together,” you thought of Jesus Christ who said of His covenant relationship with those who believe in and live for Him, “Abide in Me, and I in you” (John 15:4 NASB) – that would certainly explain and make the recurring line, “it lasts forever” even more poignant given the fact that Christ also said, “This is eternal life, that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent.” (John 17:3 NASB)
Yes, all these themes and ideas are certainly there – surprisingly there’s great depth in this simple yet powerful song. I confess that I have listened to this song through tears on many an occasion since, for me, it echoes all these themes and resonates deeply within. Here, try it for yourself:
Yes, folks believe it or not, this deep and beautiful song was written and performed by Eddie and Alex Van Halen, Sammy Haggar, and Michael Anthony – that is, to use the words of one reviewer, that “band of idiots” known to the world as Van Halen.
After all they’re not immune to the deeply seeded need that all humans have to know unconditional love and acceptance. Whether it’s a straight arrow, feet-on-the-ground world pastor or a jelly brained, out-of-touch rock star we all feel this need – and clearly the guys in Van Halen do too.
Nor, apparently, is Van Halen any more immune to incorrectly diagnosing the “fix” as romantic love than anyone else is – as the video illustrates well. My hope and prayer for these guys that someday, somehow, the they “get” the wisdom of St. Augustine that “our hearts are restless till they find rest in Thee.” Perhaps on that day they’ll join us in singing this song through tears of fulfilled joy rather than longing, despair, and confusion.
Beggar's Bread 